Of Cold Syrup

Comments

[this is good]

Welcome to the group. I enjoyed reading this, it captured my attention. I think the flashbacks work in that they are short enough to not distract from the main thread, but contribute to character development and context. And I love the dialogue! You seem to have a talent for it. It sounds quite natural.

Thanks for the feedback man, I appreciate it. I've always loved it when writers can intertwine dialog and pertinent flashbacks so I thought I'd give it a whirl.
[this is good]

Very good piece. Dan is right; your dialogue does flow nicely. I like that you have the dialogue go on just long enough uninterrupted that the reader doesn't get annoyed when Carter's mind travels. Also, the dialogue's at the perfect length that you don't need to interrupt it with "he said" or some other tag. However, I would suggest that you pay attention to something.

Before going to bed last night, I just skimmed over your posts. On one of your other posts, you started three consecutive paragraphs with "So." I may have noticed that because in my natural voice, I have to stop myself from beginning all my blogpost paragraphs with "so" or "however." Here, you repeat Carter's name a lot where you could replace it with "he." For example, the first two paragraphs start with "Carter." The four major paragraphs actually start rather similar: "Carter was" "Carter had" "Carter had" "George was" I have a friend that I help edit for and when she first writes something, she uses an inordinate amount of the characters' names. Afterwards, she goes back in and replaces some of them. Perhaps you do something similar.

I really enjoyed your subtle characterizations. For example, "Her success lied in her ability to make everyone feel they were the only ones she wasn't screwing over." I have known many of those girls. And I like that you remembered to draw that characterization out to include how it would've affected her brother, as well. Very good. I really liked the piece. Also, it'd be great if you could stop by this thread and tell the group a little more about yourself. Thanks!

The four major paragraphs actually start rather similar: "Carter was" "Carter had" "Carter had" "George was"

Thanks for pointing that out! I really didn't notice, but I've always had a problem with that sort of thing.

I really enjoyed your subtle characterizations.

Thanks! I would be lying if I wasn't proud of writing that bit. :)

Also, it'd be great if you could stop by this thread and tell the group a little more about yourself.

Also, it'd be great if you could stop by this thread and tell the group a little more about yourself.

Done!



[this is good]
Huh, I was wondering if you wrote this yourself or if this was out of a book you liked,... and wanted to share or something. Given the comments left I have my answer.

But yeah, I like it; it has a good flow to it. So are there going to be weekly installments or what? :)
[this is good]
nice story,very catchy!
Thanks for the compliments. Hopefully there will be weekly installments, but really I just have to write it in the right mood. I'm trying to turn this into a short Novel. So stay posted 'cause there will definitely be a lot more of this to come, it just all depends on me being in the correct frame of mind.
[this is good]
This is more than good, this is spectacular. I say that, because honest to god, it reads to me like a short film. I can vividly see the layout and the characters. It would verywell be a one act play. I like how you leave the ending with unlimited possibilities, and by the way, thanks for joining the group. I've had very limited internet access so I haven't been able to check much of anything, including email, but anyway, keep up the good work and I most definitely look forward to reading more from you!
[this is good]

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in

Gdub

About Me

Gdub
United States
I'm a genious, I'm just too lazy to do anything about it!

Archives

Twitter